Stock Market is a Bad Economic Indicator

Feb 28, 2009 | By: Mr_Blue | Tags: economy, stock market, economic indicators

We have been programmed, or at the least unintentionally misled, into believing that the stock market is a good measure of how the economy is doing.  We hear it in passing in the news everyday: “The Stock Market closed down today on news that” something happened and because of that piece of information we think the economy is not doing well.  This is not a good way to look at our economy particularly with our current economic crisis.

What do they mean by the “stock market”?  The news sound bites about the stock market usually refer to one of three indices:

  1. Dow Jones Industrial Average - measures the stock performance of 30 “blue chip” U.S. companies.
  2. S&P 500 - measures the stock performance (value weighted) of 500 large capitalization common stocks actively traded in the U.S.
  3. Nasdaq Composite Index - measures all NASDAQ U.S. and international based common stock listed on the NASDAQ Stock Market.

These indices are excellent measures of how the equity or stock market is doing but that is it.  Contrary to what I was taught in business school the stock market is not rational.  The stock market is nothing more than a place for people or entities to exchange something of value.  The stock market is prone to whims and herd mentality.  Stock values or prices are often not even based on balance sheet fundamentals.  For instance, remember not to long ago - internet craze/bubble where some internet company stocks were reaching over $100 per share based on nothing more than idea that the internet will solve all of our problems.  These internet companies had negative cash flows and were projecting no income for years but the stock market valued them at $150 per share.

Our current economic crisis is another reason why we cannot rely on the stock market as an economic indicator.  First, according to the National Bureau of Economic Research our current recession official began in December 2007.  But, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was hovering above 13,000 not far from its record 14,000 point mark.  Today, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is at 7,000.  Second, our current economic crisis began in the credit markets and truly is a crisis of credit (debt instruments) versus equity (stocks).  If anything, we should be paying attention to credit market indicators to determine if our economy is improving.  If this is too complicated then there are the more published indicators such gross national product (GNP) reports and unemployment rate reports (although often understates true unemployment).

Good luck.

blog comments powered by Disqus


economy financial+crisis budget+deficit obama unemployment jobs credit+cards debt social+security personal+finance capitalism deficit bailout mortgage mortgage+crisis economic+crisis wall+street+bailout new+economy job+guarantee retirement+savings credit+unions deficit+hawks economic+stimulus cooperatives health+care+reform financial+regulatory+reform income+inequality tarp financial+oligarchy 401k worker+cooperatives gdp federal+debt financial+conglomerates new+normal money scams fiat+currency debt+management globalization savings neoliberal consumer+protection stimulus unemployment+rate tax+cuts middle+class wall+street investing consumer+debt investments china economic+growth federal+reserve wages federal+deficit democrats republicans stocks government+spending negative+equity risk foreclosure budget financial+planning credit+card+debt debt+settlement jobs+report financial+bailout fiscal+policy evil pete+peterson health+care financial+literacy jobs+crisis foreclosures move+your+money full+employment modern+monetary+theory stock+market neo-liberal checking economic+policy u.s.+treasuries job+growth bonds economic+mobility bank+of+america foreclosure+fraud taxes consumer+spending cfpa ira class+war inflation keynes gold fico+scores refinance credit+scores real+estate debt+crisis banking+system mortgage+foreclosure financial+regulation financial+crisis+inquiry+commission deficit+commission debt+servitude krugman federal+budget de-regulation solidarity free+trade wisconsin debt+collection income+tax refinancing loan+modifications financial+stability+plan poverty trickle+down+economics working+class retirement currency wills economics #finreg tbtf monthly+budget estate+planning consumer+credit debt+ceiling auto+industry president+obama gold+standard center+for+responsible+lending mutual+funds innocent+fraud aig life+insurance personal+income market+fundamentalism consumer+financial+protection+agency trade+deficit banking identity+theft cash+flow compound+interest fraud too+big+to+fail fdic state+of+the+union predatory net+worth u.s.+treasury+securities class+warfare bankruptcy mortgages derivatives goldman+sachs great+recession debt+consolidation eu american+recovery+and+reinvestment+act oligarchy two+economies frontline senate+democrats eurozone debt+commission haymarket existing+home+sales jobless+recovery carried+interest john+edwards income regulations ben+bernanke california+budget catfood employee+ownership paladino robert+reich mark+to+market budgets payroll+tax euro chicago+idea fannie+mae housing+market cowards slavery dollar sector+balances gmac life+settlements tax+holiday ireland mlk subprime bad+bank bullshit target+date+mutual+funds argentina fierce savings+plan alan+greenspan deficit+errorists payroll+tax+holiday phone+scams financial+regulations national+debt free+markets united+states now savings+bonds shadow+banking+system fica+tax madison time+value+of+money cost+of+unemployment ponzi+schemes swipe+fees credit+markets fair+debt+collection+practices+act tax+code #wallstreetscam great+divergence paulson future+value pensions fed+audit debit+cards predatory+home+lenders cash cdo walker warren+buffett treasury+department present+value tax+deal cooperative+economy liquidity u.s.+debt poverty+rates conservatives ppip job+loss 20-year+mortgage obama+tax+deal short+sales cash+management treasury+securities detroit+schools home+buying economic+purgatory long+term+unemployment vicious+cycle bartering emergency+savings efca debt+hysteria home+closing banks deficit+hawk american+capitalism community+gardens economic community+banks debt+to+gdp recession austerity online+scams income+taxes investment inequality estate investment+yields happy+year finreg hyman+minsky american+dream email beige+book mortgage+modifications yuan risk-return investment+advice dot+com+bubble leading+economic+indicators malicious+software deflation corporate+bailouts federal business+roundtable cooperation returns housing+bubble chris+dodd lei deferred+annuities bailouts economic+policies balancing+checkbook alternatives disability+income+insurance scam fiscal+sustainability home+mortgage fixed+rate+annuity lobbyists debt+is+evil deficit+spending tina balance+check+book credit+report teach-in currency+manipulation bill+gross insurance variable+rate+annuity corporate+tax+breaks credit+card+law race+to+bottom big+banks marx june+jobs+report general+motors economic+indicators budgeting financialization warren+mosler washington+consensus foreclosure+rescue+services gross+domestic+product new+capitalist+manifesto bank+fees credit+card minsky tips open+auction lost+decade financial+genocide republican+budget emergency human+capital direct+deposit reaganomics overdraft cfpb galbraith social+security+cards geithner commercial+real+estate direct+jobs+program civil+disobedience balance etf economic+justice barack+obama worker+ownership personal+consumption treasuries protests gas+prices obama+administration destruction citizens+united outlays wall+street+bailouts exports household+debt fallacy+of+composition securities+laws save public+option living+standard unions july+2011 unemployment+benefits imports card+act fallacies emergency+funds deductibles strategic+defaults keynesian wiped+out productivity+ralph+nader new+era+windows laid+off citigroup financial+sector foreclosure+gate auto+loans human+capitalism savings+tip financial+reform arra free+credit+report chicago money+market+accounts unemployment+insurance fox+news+channel credit+rating+agencies credit+reports fallacy money+market+mutual+funds afl-cio fox move+money predatory+lending refund+anticipation+loans jobs+data moody's revolution tax+reform uaw employment principal+reduction roger+ailes close+banking+accounts countervailing+powers tax+refund debt+forgiveness lehman+brothers cornel+west exuberance denmark propaganda banking+services john+k.+galbraith monetary+policy option+arm mortgage+loan+modifications subprime+mortgages corporate+profits disposable+income national+infrastructure+bank corporate+welfare u.s money+manager+capitalism birth+certificate fundamentals living+wage output+gap success consumption interest+rates greece quantitative+easing political+system john+mccain minimum+wage new+democrat+coalition two+americas ltcm universal+health+care income+distribution household

Mythbusters - 300x250